Ranch dressing has become America’s favorite condiment, but not all ranch dressings are created equal. After extensive testing and analysis of the most popular brands, we’ve ranked them from disappointing to outstanding. Whether you’re dipping vegetables or dressing a salad, this ranking will help you make an informed choice for your next purchase.
Newman’s Own ranch dressing needs improvement
Starting at the bottom of our rankings, Newman’s Own ranch dressing disappointed with its oil-heavy profile and minimal ranch flavor. The dressing’s consistency resembles mayonnaise more than traditional ranch, and the herbaceous notes that define a good ranch dressing are notably absent.
What if Newman’s Own focused more on balancing their herbs and spices? The potential is there, but currently, this option falls short of expectations. For those who have this in their fridge, try adding fresh herbs to enhance the flavor profile.
Briannas ranch brings unexpected sweetness
Briannas ranch dressing presents an interesting case of mistaken identity. While the texture hits the mark with its creamy consistency, the unexpected sweetness throws off the traditional ranch profile. Some might appreciate this unique twist, but ranch purists should look elsewhere.
The thickness works well for dipping, but the sweet notes overshadow the essential garlic and herb elements that define ranch dressing. Consider this option if you prefer sweeter dressings, but recognize it’s a departure from classic ranch flavors.
Hidden Valley maintains its iconic status
The original ranch creator maintains a solid position in the middle of the pack. Hidden Valley’s thick consistency works perfectly for dipping, but some find the flavor muted compared to newer competitors.
Many remember Hidden Valley as their introduction to ranch dressing, and it remains a reliable choice. The recipe hasn’t changed much over the years, which speaks to its staying power but also reveals why more innovative brands have surpassed it.
Ken’s Steakhouse serves restaurant quality
Ken’s Steakhouse ranch dressing proves that shelf-stable options can rival their refrigerated counterparts. This dressing strikes an impressive balance between creaminess and pourability, with a well-rounded flavor profile that includes just the right amount of garlic, herbs, and tanginess.
The consistency works equally well as a dip or dressing, and the balanced sweetness enhances rather than overwhelms. Restaurant owners often choose Ken’s for its reliability and crowd-pleasing flavor profile.
Whole Foods 365 ranks supreme
Taking the top spot, Whole Foods 365 ranch dressing rivals the best restaurant offerings. The subtle garlic kick elevates this dressing above its competitors, while maintaining the classic ranch profile that consumers expect.
The balance of herbs and spices creates a sophisticated flavor that works on salads, as a dip, or even as a marinade. The creamy texture strikes the perfect balance – thick enough to coat vegetables but still pourable for salads.
Selecting the right ranch dressing depends on personal preference and intended use. While our top picks offer the best overall experience, each brand brings something unique to the table. Remember that refrigerated options generally provide fresher flavors but require more careful storage and have shorter shelf lives than their shelf-stable counterparts.
